|
|
PHILADELPHIA
EAGLES
Pro
Sports Daily
Official
Site USA
Today
Pro
Football Weekly
Eagles Stats
ESPN
2009
draft 2008
draft 2007 draft
2006 draft
2005
draft 2004
draft 2003
draft 2002
draft
2009
DRAFT PICKS
links go to
NFL.com website
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
School |
Jay's
ranking |
Jay's
draft value |
| 1 |
19 |
Jeremy
Maclin |
WR |
Missouri |
#2
WR |
Round
1 |
| 2 |
53 |
LeSean
McCoy |
RB |
Pittsburgh |
#8
RB |
Round
3 |
| 5 |
153 |
Cornelius
Ingram |
TE |
Florida |
#6
TE |
Round
3 |
| 5 |
157 |
Victor
Harris |
CB |
Virginia
Tech |
#6
CB |
Round
2 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
In
one-on-one's played better earlier in the week - he looked good
both in press coverage and playing off the line. He had a
nice end zone interception in 11 on 11's. |
|
Senior
Bowl Game |
Harris
played very well and very consistently in pass defense. He
also stood out with good coverage on a punt return. He did
not have any stand out punt returns. |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher than
him. |
Harris
a quick corner who may be best served with a team that plays
zone. Harris mirrors receivers very well, breaks well on
the ball, and is a sure tackler. Best of all, he has the
make-up of a successful corner. He will have a long and
successful NFL career. |
| 5 |
159 |
Fenuki
Tupou |
OT |
Oregon |
#14
OT |
Round
4 |
|
East
West Shrine Game |
Tupou
had a very good game both in pass protection and blocking in the
run game. |
| 6 |
194 |
Brandon
Gibson |
WR |
Washington
State |
#25
WR |
Round
5 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
Strong
kid, gets off the jam on the line very well. Looked solid, not
spectacular; steady hands except for one bad drop. |
| 7 |
213 |
Paul
Fanaika |
OG |
Arizona
State |
NR |
7th/FA |
| 7 |
230 |
Moise
Fokou |
OLB |
Maryland |
#12
OLB |
Round
4 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
| Fokou
had a nice play on run in 11 on 11's and did very well in
the one-on-one's. |
|
ONE
ON ONE BLOCKING DRILLS SCORED BY JAY GOLDBERG |
| 5
- 2 |
Davis
2-1 Hill 0-1 Foster
2-0 Jennings 1-0 |
|
| FA |
---- |
Josh
Gaines |
DE |
Penn
State |
NR |
7th/FA |
| FA |
---- |
Reshard
Langford |
SS |
Vanderbilt |
NR |
Late
Round Value |
| FA |
---- |
Marcus
Mailei |
FB |
Weber
State |
NR |
Late
Round Value |
| FA |
---- |
Dallas
Reynolds |
OC/OG |
BYU |
NR |
7th/FA |
|
B-
|
2009
COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD
|
by
Jay Goldberg
|
|
The
Eagles only had two picks in the first four rounds, and in my
mind, I would have gone in a different direction with their
pick in round two. Other than that I cannot argue with
their selections based on where they drafted and their
needs. However, I was not overly impressed with the
college street free agents they signed.
DRAFT
PICKS
Macklin
was an excellent get by the Eagles. He give the team
three receivers (Jackson and Curtis are the other two) who are
reliable pass catchers, with good speed and quickness, who can
make big plays. However, the Eagles "big
three" are not very big or very physical.
I
had four running backs still on the board rated more highly
than McCoy. For a big back to compliment Westbrook, I
liked Green. For a similar skilled back I liked
Goodson. For a combo back I liked Andre Brown.
However, I would have passed on all three here and drafted my
top rated tight end, Shawn Nelson at this spot. With
Nelson's receiving skills, he would have filled the need for
big target who could also get down the field. I
especially would have drafted Nelson since my favorite of all
the backs available at this spot, Javon Ringer, was going to
be available later in the draft. Now, why did I have
four other running backs rated more highly than McCoy?
His lack of speed and athleticism in his workout meant that
there was a higher probability of failure with McCoy,
especially at this spot in the draft, than there was with the
other backs. Before you shout that McCoy showed good
quickness and change-of-direction skills in workouts, know
that Ringer's numbers (3.72 short shuttle, 6.66 three-cone)
were much better than Shady McCoy's numbers (4.18 short
shuttle, 6.82 three-cone), and Ringer was pretty darn
productive at Michigan State as well.
Given
the prior two selections, Ingram was good value and a logical
pick here. He will develop into a solid NFL tight
end. However, in my scenario, after drafting Nelson in
round two, I would have grabbed my main man Javon Ringer here.
Macho
Harris was a great pick in round five. I had a second
round grade on this kid. He has good skills, is very
quick, is a ballhawk, is a confident player, and will
eventually be a top starter for the Eagles.
Tupou
was an underrated and overlooked prospect in this draft.
He played a very nice game at the East West Shrine Game.
Worst case, he should have a career as a capable
reserve. He is a better player on the field than he is a
workout warrior.
Gibson
was worth a shot in round six. During the Senior Bowl
practices he looked very strong, getting off jams on the line
and fighting for the ball. Then he went out and lifted
the bar only 10 times. So is he not as strong as he
looked, or is horrible at bench pressing? The answer to
that question will determine his fate. With his lack of
speed, Gibson's role will have to be that of a physical
receiver who is a plus on special teams coverage units.
The
Eagles had Fanaika higher on their board than he was on
mine. He needs work in the weight room. I liked
the potential of guard Ryan Durand more, and he would have
been my selection here.
The
Eagles have to have been thrilled that Fokou was available at
#230. I had a fourth round grade on him and I actually
give him a shot to get into the battle for the starting WILL
at some point during the season. In the meantime, he
will be a good special teams player.
COLLEGE
STREET FREE AGENTS
Gaines
is a strong kid, who could develop into a early down end and
goal line player as a force against the run. But, he
will probably have to do so from the Eagles development squad
(if at all). Langford
is athletic enough to be a force on special teams, but will
need to excel there since his upside as a safety is somewhat
limited. Mailei
has good hands, something the Eagles like in fullbacks, but
faces long odds to make the team. Reynolds
best asset is his versatility. He is a candidate for the
Eagles' development squad since if he develops he will offer
roster flexibility. |
For
chart below: red indicates workout number in top range at position in
draft
ARM-HAND
relative to position, for ranges see ranking pages for 2009 draft
LAST
NAME
at Combine |
FIRST
NAME |
SCHOOL |
HGT |
WGT |
ARM-
HAND |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT |
LONG |
3
CONE |
VERT |
BROAD |
| Macklin |
Jeremy |
Missouri |
6'0.1" |
198 |
M-L |
- |
4.40 |
1.56 |
2.62 |
4.26 |
- |
7.12 |
35.5" |
10'0" |
| McCoy |
LeSean |
Pittsburgh |
5'11" |
197 |
M-M |
- |
4.50 |
1.52 |
2.59 |
4.18 |
- |
6.82 |
29" |
8'11" |
| Ingram |
Cornelius |
Florida |
6'3.7" |
245 |
XL-L |
21 |
4.62 |
1.53 |
2.69 |
4.53 |
- |
7.12 |
33" |
9'6" |
| Harris |
Macho |
Virginia
Tech |
5'11.2" |
198 |
M-M |
- |
4.46 |
1.50 |
2.56 |
3.98 |
- |
6.68 |
34" |
10'1" |
| Tupou |
Fenuki |
Oregon |
6'5.3" |
314 |
L-S |
24 |
5.20 |
1.73 |
2.94 |
4.85 |
- |
8.33 |
26" |
8'3" |
| Gibson |
Brandon |
Washington
State |
6'0.3" |
210 |
M-L |
10 |
4.59 |
1.63 |
2.65 |
4.54 |
- |
6.94 |
34" |
9'5" |
| Fanaika |
Paul |
Arizona
State |
6'5.1" |
327 |
XL-XL |
16 |
- |
- |
- |
4.92 |
- |
8.06 |
24.5" |
8'2" |
| Fokou |
Moise |
Maryland |
6'1.1" |
233 |
XL-XL |
21 |
4.63 |
1.57 |
2.70 |
4.28 |
11.41 |
7.09 |
33" |
10'1" |
| Gaines |
Josh |
Penn
State |
6'0.3" |
274 |
- |
28 |
4.90 |
1.68 |
2.82 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
| Langford |
Reshard |
Vanderbilt |
6'1.1" |
212 |
- |
17 |
4.68 |
1.62 |
2.69 |
4.23 |
- |
7.17 |
38" |
10'3" |
| Mailei |
Marcus |
Weber
State |
5'11.6" |
248 |
S-M |
22 |
4.88 |
1.62 |
2.78 |
4.33 |
- |
7.36 |
35" |
9'5" |
| Reynolds |
Dallas |
BYU |
6'4.3" |
309 |
- |
20 |
5.28 |
1.79 |
2.98 |
5.03 |
- |
7.59 |
30" |
8'2" |
2009 NEEDS PRIOR TO DRAFT AND FREE
AGENCY
Major need
Need
Upgrade possible
Depth/possible need
Not a need
| QB |
McNabb is under contract,
should be back and will be back. If the Eagles trade him
and go to Kolb they will be in trouble. I expect Kolb's
success to more like Beck the Miami quarterback than Beck
the singer. I'm not convinced that A. J. Feeley isn't the
better option at backup quarterback. |
| RB |
Westbrook is a great
back. Buckhalter is underrated and an UFA who some team
could give a chance to compete for significant playing time.
Booker was a disappointment. Look for the Eagles to add a
banger in the draft to help in short yardage and goal line
situations and possibly replace Buckhalter as Westbrook's
primary backup. There are good options in the draft. |
| WR |
This unit is much
maligned but is better than given credit for. I like the
Jackson. I like Curtis. Both can stretch the field.
Jackson can take a short pass and go the distance. Curtis
has reliable hands and is a great route runner. Avant,
Baskett, Brown and Lewis are all NFL-caliber receivers, but yes
upgrades can be found. What is needed here is a big
receiver to pair with Curtis moving Jackson to the slot.
However, you can do a lot worse than having Jackson and Curtis
as your starters. |
| TE |
Smith is an UFA, and with
Celek passing him by, he will most likely move on. That
means the Eagles will need a quality tight end to pair with
Celek. |
| OL |
For a team that throws as
often as the Eagles do, the Eagles were 7th in the league giving
up only 23 sacks. However, starting tackles Runyon and
Thomas are UFAs and at their advanced ages decisions have to
made as to whom to resign (my guess LT Thomas is back, RT Runyon
is not). Inside the Eagles blocked well and Jean-Gilles
started showing the talent I knew he had before getting injured.
A right tackle will probably be needed. |
| DL |
This is a team strength.
At end the team goes five deep. Inside Patterson and
Bunkley form a terrific young duo and Haws is a fine young third
tackle. |
| LB |
Bradley played better
than I expected in the middle. Gocong looks like a keeper
at SAM. Gaither took a step back this year and was
replaced by Jordan who looked very good in the regular season
but was no where to be found during the playoffs. An
upgrade at WILL is possible. |
| DB |
Samuel and Brown are a
top pair starting corners. Hansen's solid play makes
trading Sheppard more likely. At safety starter Dawkins
and backup/special teams ace Considine are UFAs. Dawkins
is probably going nowhere, but the Eagles have his replacement
in place with Quintin Demps. Mikell has developed into a
top strong safety. |
| ST |
A very solid unit with
Akers, Rocca, Demps and Jackson. |
2008
DRAFT PICKS
links go to
NFL.com website
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
Ht. |
Wt. |
School |
Jay's ranking |
Jay's draft value |
| 2 |
47 |
Trevor
Laws |
DT |
6'0.6" |
304 |
N Dame |
#4 DT |
Round 1/Round 2 |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher
than him.
|
Laws
hustles all the time and makes a lot of tackles. He is
also strong, quick and fast for a 300 pound man. Laws
can play inside in a 4-3 defense, but also has the skill set
to play end in a 3-4. Laws is one of those players that
looks like an overachiever, but isn't, he's just very good and
very talented. Would I draft him in round one? As
Tom Cullen (The Stand) would say, Laws yes! |
| 2 |
49 |
DeSean
Jackson |
WR/Ret |
5'9.6" |
169 |
California |
#4 WR |
Round 1/Round 2 |
| 3 |
80 |
Bryan
Smith |
OLB |
6'2.3" |
231 |
McNeese St |
|
Late Round Value |
| 4 |
109 |
Mike
McGlynn |
OT/OG |
6'4" |
311 |
Pittsburgh |
#14 OT |
Round 4 |
| 4 |
117 |
Quintin
Demps |
FS/Ret |
5'11" |
206 |
UTEP |
#2 FS |
Round 2/Round 3 |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher
than him.
|
Demps
has the best man-to-man cover skills of all the pure safeties
in the draft (not including the corners being projected to
safety). He has the speed to line up in coverage against
running backs split wide and tight ends who are bulked up wide
receivers. He also has excellent ball skills, gets lots
of turnovers and is a good punt and kickoff returner. He
needs to be a more reliable tackler, but I believe that will
come in time. |
| 4 |
131 |
Jack
Ikegwuonu |
CB |
5'10.4" |
194 |
Wisconsin |
|
Late Round Value |
| 6 |
184 |
Mike
Gibson |
OG/OT |
6'3.5" |
305 |
California |
#7 OG |
Round 3/Round 4 |
| 6 |
200 |
Joe
Mays |
ILB |
5'11" |
245 |
N Dakota St |
|
Free Agent |
| 6 |
203 |
Andy
Studebaker |
OLB/DE |
6'3" |
251 |
Wheaton |
|
Free Agent |
| 7 |
230 |
King
Dunlap |
OT |
6'8.5" |
310 |
Auburn |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Jed Collins |
FB/TE |
6'1.6" |
254 |
Wash St |
|
Late Round
Value/Free Agent |
| FA |
|
Franklyn Dunbar |
OT |
6'4.3" |
327 |
Mid Ten St |
|
Late Round
Value/Free Agent |
| FA |
|
Shaheer McBride |
WR |
6'1.4" |
205 |
Delaware St |
|
Late Round
Value/Free Agent |
top
|
The
Eagles draft was all over the place. They had some great
picks (Laws, Demps, Gibson), a head-scratcher (Smith) and
missed a player I would have pulled the trigger on (strong
safety Josh Barrett) by a wide margin over Mays or Studebaker
in round six. Barrett would have been been better on
special teams than either player and could develop into a very
good starting strong safety in a year or two, a position of
need for the Eagles with Considine (a player whose skills I
like) always getting hurt. The Eagles didn't sign any
college street free agents that blew my mind.
DRAFT
PICKS
Laws
is a player I like a lot. He goes all out on every play,
is very strong and very quick, and is a player the Philly fans
will appreciate. He should be part of a three man
rotation immediately, and, in time, will be a player they will
find hard to keep off the field (both because of his talent
and his attitude). Laws was a great pick.
Jackson
was another nice selection by Philly. While players like
Sweed and Hawkins may have a higher upside since both have the
skills to be a #1 receiver and Jackson is a clear #2 or #3; he
was an excellent fit for the Eagles. Now some of you
will complain that the Eagles could use a #1 receiver,
however, there were no top tier #1's available. Also,
the Eagle fans (and national media) greatly under-appreciate
Kevin Curtis, a former member of my list of players who will
have a better NFL career than many drafted higher than them.
Just a reminder, scout Matt Gambil had these numbers for
Curtis at his on campus workout: 39 1/2" vertical, 4.27
forty, 20 reps. Now back to Jackson. He will provide the
Eagles with another speedy receiver and a good return man.
When he is on the field with Curtis and Brown, McNabb can
confidently go where the coverage dictates and feel confident
the ball will be caught, and the receiver has good YAC.
The
Eagles had Smith rated more highly than me. He was an
undersized defensive end who got double-digit sacks his last
two years at McNeese State who projects to outside linebacker
in the NFL because of his size. However, as an outside
linebacker his speed and quickness are only average so I'm not
sure he will be able to transfer his skills to be a starting
linebacker in the NFL. As fifth round selection, he
would be worth the risk. Not as a third round pick.
If the Eagles wanted a linebacker here who could play the
strong side, Stanford Keglar would have been my pick. If
they wanted a smallish pass rushing defensive end with a
chance to play linebacker here, Marcus Howard would have been
my pick.
McGlynn
is a strong kid with quick feet who will be a versatile sub.
He played tackle in college, but may be best suited for guard
in the NFL. He does have enough skills to develop into a
reliable starter down the road.
Demps
is a smart, speedy free safety who has a nose for the ball,
and has above average cover skills. Immediately, Demps
is an ideal nickel safety. Long term he could be a good
replacement for Dawkins. He is not a good fit at strong
safety since he is better in coverage playing the run.
Ikegwuonu
would have been a third round value if he didn't get injured
prior to the draft (knee). He won't play this year, and
next year will be a recovery year, but if he bounces all the
way back the Eagles will have a heady, physical corner who
fits their scheme.
Gibson
has the measureables, the toughness and the attitude to
succeed. He needs work on his technique. I expect
him to be a better pro long tem than McGlynn.
Mays
and Studebaker are linebackers from small college programs.
Personally, I would have grabbed strong safety Josh Barrett
with one of these picks. Mays is short, not particularly fast
or quick, but is instinctive and was the defensive player of
the year in his conference. He can play the run but is
limited in pass defense. He will be a good special teams
player.
Studebaker
is a small college pass rusher who also shows good pursuit
against the run. He was injured much of his senior year
but had 17.5 sacks as a junior. He projects as a
possible pass rush specialist. While some see him as
similar to Gocong, Gocong was on my "list" (like
Curtis), and Studebaker was off my board.
Dunlap
has tremendous size. He will need time to develop and is
an ideal practice squad candidate.
COLLEGE
STREET FREE AGENTS
Collins
is a blocker who could play in the backfield or on the line.
There is an opportunity for him at fullback, not a deep
position for Philly.
Dunbar
is another offensive lineman (Dunlap) who could win a spot on
the Eagles practice squad. He is skilled, but slow.
McBride
has good hands and plays better on the field than he performs
at workouts. Still, he has his work cut out for him to
make this team.
|
red
indicates workout number in top range at position in draft
(blue
college name indicates workout #'s include Pro Day numbers)
COMBINE
YES |
FIRST
NAME |
SCHOOL |
HEIGHT |
WEIGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT |
LONG |
3
CONE |
VERT |
BROAD |
| Laws |
Trevor |
NOTRE
DAME |
6'0.6" |
304 |
35 |
5.13 |
1.74 |
2.94 |
4.39 |
NA |
7.37 |
30.5" |
8'7" |
| Jackson |
DeSean |
CALIFORNIA |
5'9.6" |
169 |
NA |
4.31 |
1.55 |
2.53 |
4.19 |
NA |
6.82 |
34.5" |
10'2" |
| Smith |
Bryan |
McNEESE
ST |
6'2.3" |
231 |
17 |
4.65 |
1.56 |
2.67 |
4.31 |
NA |
7.20 |
36.5" |
10'0" |
| McGlynn |
Mike |
PITTSBURGH |
6'4" |
311 |
30 |
5.36 |
1.89 |
3.11 |
4.72 |
NA |
7.58 |
23" |
8'5" |
| Demps |
Quintin |
UTEP |
5'11" |
206 |
16 |
4.38 |
1.51 |
2.53 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
31.5" |
9'2" |
| Ikegwuono |
Jack |
WISCONSIN |
5'10.4" |
194 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
| Gibson |
Mike |
CALIFORNIA |
6'3.5" |
305 |
31 |
5.21 |
1.77 |
3.00 |
4.63 |
NA |
7.21 |
29.5" |
9'2" |
| Mays |
Joe |
N
DAKOTA ST |
5'11" |
245 |
21 |
4.70 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
33.5" |
9'3" |
| Studebaker |
Andy |
WHEATON |
6'3" |
251 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
| Dunlap |
King |
AUBURN |
6'8.5" |
310 |
21 |
5.26 |
1.75 |
2.99 |
5.12 |
NA |
8.05 |
30" |
NA |
| Collins |
Jed |
WASH
ST |
6'1.6" |
254 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
4.08 |
NA |
6.90 |
NA |
NA |
| Dunbar |
Franklyn |
MID
TEN ST |
6'4.3" |
327 |
27 |
5.62 |
1.92 |
3.19 |
5.18 |
NA |
8.36 |
24.5" |
8'5" |
| McBride |
Shaheer |
DELAWARE
ST |
6'1.4" |
205 |
NA |
4.61 |
1.52 |
2.72 |
4.48 |
NA |
7.12 |
29" |
9'4" |
2008 NEEDS
PRIOR TO DRAFT AND FREE AGENCY
PHI
Major
Need Need
Upgrade Depth
Need Not
a Need
| QB |
McNabb
will continue to heal and will return to Pro Bowl form.
The Eagles better hope they don't move him in the offseason.
Kolb was a bit of the reach in the draft and I'm not sure he
will ever be a star NFL quarterback. Feeley is a solid
backup. If McNabb is moved, a quarterback will be
needed. |
| RB |
Westbrook
is a great player. Buckhalter is a very good backup, but
Philly keeps looking to replace him. Hunt is not the
answer as Westbrook's backup because he is too slow. He
could develop into a short yardage back. |
| WR |
I
get annoyed every time I hear that the Eagles don't have good
receivers. Curtis is a very good player. He has
excellent hands, is a tough kid, and has game breaking speed.
He was a great free agent signing. Brown is also a solid
player. While I agree, a big target with more skills and
speed than Baskett would be an upgrade, it is far from a
crying need. Avant has the look of a reliable slot
receiver. Lewis makes this unit five deep. |
| TE |
Smith
is a free agent who the Eagles won't break the bank to resign
because he has gotten nicked up a bit too much recently.
Celek has good hands and is a valuable player, but does not
have the ability to stretch the field. Look for the
Eagles to bring in a tight end who can push to start. |
| OL |
This
is a good unit with decent depth, particularly at guard.
The Eagles could take a shot with a tackle who could challenge
Justice to be the eventual successor at left tackle. |
| DL |
The
Eagles have good young talent on their defensive line.
They could add a defensive end with size to play opposite
Cole, and a backup tackle to compete for playing time. |
| LB |
The
Eagles have a solid vet in Spikes and some good young players
at this spot. Spikes will carry a big price tag next
year so it will be interesting if he is invited back. If
he is let go, the Eagles may look to add a veteran presence to
their young corps. |
| DB |
This
unit may get a facelift in the offseason. Brown and
Sheppard are no longer one of the top pair of corners in the
league. Sheppard gets banged up too much and Brown may
be best served going forward as a slot corner. At
safety, Dawkins is still a very good player but he is getting
up there in years. Considine has some skills at strong
safety, but is small for the position and was injured for the
second year in a row. Look for Philly to add a corner or
two, a strong safety to compete to start, and possibly a young
free safety to apprentice behind Dawkins. |
| ST |
The
Eagles need a return man and a punter to challenge Rocca. |
2007
DRAFT PICKS
links go to
NFL.com website
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
Ht. |
Wt. |
School |
Jay's Ranking |
Jay's Draft Value |
| 2 |
36 |
Kolb,
Kevin |
QB |
6-3 |
220 |
Houston |
# 5 QB |
Round 3 |
| 2 |
57 |
Abiamiri,
Victor |
DE |
6-5 |
271 |
Notre
Dame |
#10 DE |
Round 3 |
| 3 |
87 |
Bradley,
Stewart |
OLB |
6-4 |
256 |
Nebraska |
# 7 OLB |
Round 3 |
| 3 |
90 |
Hunt,
Tony |
RB |
6-0 |
230 |
Penn
State |
#10 RB |
Round 4 |
| 5 |
159 |
Gaddis,
C.J. |
FS |
6-0 |
210 |
Clemson |
#15 CB |
Round 4 |
| 5 |
162 |
Celek,
Brent |
TE |
6-4 |
261 |
Cincinnati |
|
Late Round Value |
| 6 |
201 |
Barksdale,
Rashad |
CB |
6-0 |
208 |
Albany |
|
Off My Board |
| 7 |
236 |
Ilaoa,
Nate |
FB |
5-8 |
248 |
Hawaii |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Clark, Jeremy |
DT |
6-3 |
309 |
Alabama |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Faulkner, Dereck |
WR |
6-3 |
225 |
Hampton |
|
Off My Board |
| FA |
|
Paschal, Marcus |
FS |
6-0 |
201 |
Iowa |
|
Off My Board |
|
The
Eagles reached a bit for Kolb and Hunt, but got good value with
Gaddis in round five. They also followed up a so-so draft
(in my opinion) with so-so college free agent signings (again in
my opinion).
The Eagles traded out of round one and selected Kolb in round
two. While I agree with the trade, I wouldn't have made
the move to draft Kolb. I had Stanton and Edwards rated
higher than Kolb, and I especially liked Edwards for Philly.
I would have grabbed cornerback Chris Houston with the first
pick and then Edwards was on the board for both of the Eagles
third round selections. I would have drafted Edwards
instead of Hunt. While I had a third round grade on
Abiamiri, I cannot find fault in the Eagles drafting him in
round two. He has the skills and build to be a two-way
end, playing against the run with the ability to rush the
passer, although he won't be stud sack artist. Bradley is
a rarity. He is a solid, pure 4-3 SAM linebacker with the
strength to play off blocks and make tackles and the quickness
to cover most tight ends. He could give GoCong a run for
his money for the Eagle's starting job. Hunt is a strong
between the tackles runner who the Eagles grabbed too high.
It's not his lack of speed that concerns me most, but his lack
of quickness; he ran a horrible 4.72 short shuttle. He
could help in short yardage situations, but is not the back to
spot with Brain Westbrook. Gaddis was a nice get in round
five. He has upside as both a corner and a safety, and
will be a very good special teams player. Put it all
together and he should become a very valuable sub. Celek
got noticed at the East West Shrine Game, showing reliable
hands. He will never be a star but will be a solid backup
tight end, although he needs work on his blocking.
Barksdale is a fast, athletic strong safety with good cover
skills for a strong safety. He is a good fit as a dime
back and special teams player. Ilaoa is a strong kid who
is tough to bring down and is an effective receiver. He
lacks speed but is quicker than Hunt and may be an even better
short yardage back than Hunt.
The
best player the Eagles signed during college free agency was
defensive tackle Jeremy Clark. He is a kid who was thought
to get by on effort and then put up some nice numbers at his
workout. He has the look of a long-term NFL backup.
Wide receiver Faulkner grew up rooting for the Eagles. He
is a very good athlete who should do well on special teams
coverage units. He may have to spend a year on the Eagles'
development squad before getting a chance to show his special
teams value. Paschal was a good college player who may
lack the quickness to help in the secondary or on special teams
in the NFL. However, he is worth a look based on his play
at Iowa.
|
red
indicates workout number in top range at position in draft
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| KOLB |
KEVIN |
HOUSTON |
QB |
6'3.1" |
218 |
|
4.83 |
1.64 |
2.81 |
4.44 |
|
6.94 |
32.5" |
9'4" |
| Kolb
had a monster senior year completing two-thirds of his passes
with 30 TDs and only 4 interceptions. Kolb is a very
accurate passer who played mainly in the shotgun in college.
I was a bit disappointed in his post -season work so it is
possible he was a product of the system he played in college as
much as his talent. He is an intriguing prospect. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| ABIAMIRI |
VICTOR |
NOTRE
DAME |
DE |
6'4.2" |
267 |
25 |
4.80 |
1.56 |
2.65 |
|
|
|
|
|
| Abiamiri
has the potential to develop into a solid two-way end. He
can play the run and rush the passer, although he will not be a
big-time sacker. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| BRADLEY |
STEWART |
NEBRASKA |
OLB |
6'3.6" |
254 |
28 |
4.69 |
1.56 |
2.71 |
4.17 |
11.74 |
7.29 |
35.5" |
9'4" |
| Bradley
is a pure 4-3 SAM linebacker. He is a strong kid with the
quickness to cover tight ends and the strength to take on
blockers and make plays. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| HUNT |
TONY |
PENN
ST |
RB |
6'1.5" |
233 |
24 |
4.68 |
1.60 |
2.72 |
4.72 |
|
7.39 |
31.5" |
9'2" |
| Hunt
is strong, productive, slow, between the tackles runner who
could be a good short yardage and goal line back in the NFL. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| GADDIS |
C.J. |
CLEMSON |
CB/FS |
5'11.4" |
203 |
20 |
4.45 |
1.52 |
2.58 |
4.30 |
11.73 |
7.13 |
39.5" |
10'1" |
| Gaddis
is a strong corner who is a converted safety. He is raw at
corner and may be better long term at safety since he is a good
tackler. He will also be a top special teams player. |
|
COMBINE
NO
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| CELEK |
BRENT |
CINNCINATI |
TE |
6'3.7" |
250 |
19 |
4.79 |
1.64 |
2.75 |
4.31 |
|
7.20 |
33" |
9'4" |
| Celek
had a nice week catching the ball at the East West Shrine Game.
He will need some time, but could develop into a productive
backup tight end. |
|
COMBINE
NO
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| BARKSDALE |
RICHARD |
ALBANY |
SS |
5'11.5" |
208 |
19 |
4.46 |
1.53 |
2.59 |
|
|
|
34.5" |
10'7" |
| Barksdale
is a fast, athletic safety with good cover skills for a strong
safety. He should get a long look in a team's camp. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| ILAOA |
NATE |
HAWAII |
RB |
5'8.7" |
245 |
25 |
4.77 |
1.63 |
2.75 |
4.42 |
11.78 |
7.10 |
30" |
8'7" |
| Ilaoa
is a bowling ball, and not one for kids, but one for 300 pound
men. He is a very strong kid, who runs tough, is hard to
bring down, and has surprisingly good receiving skills. He
is a situational player, but one who could be very good when
used in the correct spots. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| CLARK |
JEREMY |
ALABAMA |
DT |
6'2.4" |
309 |
29 |
5.02 |
1.64 |
2.84 |
4.82 |
|
7.78 |
31" |
9'2" |
| Surprisingly,
Clark has good measureables. He was thought to be an
effort-guy with limited athletic skills. He could be a
nice surprise for the team that drafts him late on day two. |
|
COMBINE
NO
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| FAULKNER |
DERRICK |
HAMPTON |
WR |
6'2.5" |
225 |
|
4.53 |
1.55 |
2.58 |
4.31 |
|
7.09 |
40" |
10'4" |
| Faulkner
has good size and decent speed. He is a very athletic kid
who could find his way onto a team's development squad. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| PASCHAL |
MARCUS |
IOWA |
FS |
6'0.2" |
201 |
15 |
4.59 |
1.59 |
2.71 |
4.72 |
|
7.31 |
33" |
|
| Paschal
is an active safety with a productive college career who may
have trouble transitioning his skills to the NFL. |
2007
TEAM NEEDS PRIOR TO THE DRAFT and FREE AGENCY
major
need
need
depth/possible
need
not a significant need
| QB |
McNabb
should be back, Garcia may not. Feeley is a solid backup
id Garcia leaves. |
| RB |
Westbrook
is a star, Buckhalter played well as his backup but is an UFA
and a big rookie back may be better. |
| WR |
Stallworth
is an UFA and may get big bucks to leave, Brown is a future
star, Baskett looked good. |
| TE |
Smith
is solid, but will never be top tier, Scobel can catch, if a
stud can be drafted great, otherwise just depth. |
| OL |
Philly
has one of the best lines in the league and also has good
young depth. |
| DL |
A
defensive end is needed (Kearse injury, Howard so-so year) and
Bunkley-insurance wouldn't hurt. |
| LB |
Trotter
and Jones are on their last legs. Gaither was a find,
but more LB's are needed. |
| DB |
Depth
at safety behind the starters, and a cover corner are needed
with Hood likely to leave as an UFA. |
| ST |
An
upgrade at punter is a possibility, a top tier return man
should be added. |
2006
DRAFT PICKS
Links go to write-ups at NFL.com
| Philadelphia |
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
Ht. |
Wt. |
School |
Jay's
ranking |
Jay's
draft value |
| 1 |
14 |
Bunkley,
Brodrick |
DT |
6-3 |
307 |
Florida
State |
#
2 DT |
Round
1 |
| 2 |
39 |
Justice,
Winston |
OT |
6-6 |
320 |
Southern
California |
#
2 OT |
Round
1 |
| 3 |
71 |
Gocong,
Chris |
DE |
6-2 |
264 |
Cal
Poly |
#
9 DE, # 3 Hybrid |
Round
3 |
| 4 |
99 |
Jean-Gilles,
Max |
G |
6-4 |
356 |
Georgia |
#
1 OG |
Round
1 |
| 4 |
109 |
Avant,
Jason |
WR |
6-0 |
213 |
Michigan |
Late
Round Value |
>
Round 4 |
| 5 |
147 |
Bloom,
Jeremy |
WR |
5-9 |
172 |
Colorado |
Late
Round Value |
>
Round 4 |
| 5 |
168 |
Gaither,
Omar |
OLB |
6-1 |
233 |
Tennessee |
#
12 OLB |
Round
4 |
| 6 |
204 |
Ramsey,
LaJuan |
DT |
6-2 |
296 |
Southern
California |
|
>
Round 4 |
| |
FA |
Baskett,
Hank |
WR |
6-3 |
224 |
New
Mexico |
#
14 WR |
Round
4 |
| |
FA |
Ware,
Scott |
SS |
6-1 |
213 |
USC |
Late
Round Value |
>
Round 4 |
|
The Eagles got great value
with Justice on round two and Jean-Gilles in round four., and
only slight reach was Avant with their second pick in round
four.
Bunkley was one of the elite
talents and athletes in this draft. Bunkley is immediately
one of the strongest players in the NFL; showed more quickness
in his workouts than many running backs including Addai, Norwood
and Drew and many receivers including Holmes, Jennings and Avant;
and has excellent speed and athleticism for a defensive tackle.
Bunkley should be a long term top starter for the Eagles.
Getting Justice in round two was like coming away from the draft
with not only two first round draft picks, but two elite
prospects. Justice has it all, quickness, strength, good
footwork, and athleticism. He needs some coaching (as do
most college kids coming into the NFL) so he can use his
physical talents to dominate opponents. It may take a
little time, but it will come. Justice is the second long
term top starter to come out of this draft for the Eagles.
GoCong was another great pick by the Eagles. He is even
quicker than Bunkley (tested similar to DeAnglo Williams), is a
top athlete, has good strength, and cuts very well. As a
defensive end, GoCong can play the run and rush the passer.
He also looked very good in linebacker drills at the Combine and
could move to SAM. By the way, GoCong had 98 tackles and
23.5 sacks his senior year. Long term top starter number
three for the Eagles in the draft. But wait, it doesn't
stop here. I had a first round grade on Jean-Gilles and
even stated that he was a rare guard worth a top fifteen pick
because he will be a Pro Bowl guard. Unlike the the Eagles
first three selections who are top athletes, Jean-Gilles is not
a top athlete. He is a giant man with great strength,
plays with a mean streak, and is as tough a guy as there was in
the draft. For the life of me I have no idea why he fell
as far as he did. However, the Eagles aren't complaining.
Long term top starter number four for the Eagles. If Avant
had even 4.5 speed he would have gone on day one. He has
great hands and strength and acceptable quickness but ran a 4.65
forty. His lack of speed means that Avant's ceiling may be
as a reliable third or fourth receiver who can get open in short
zones, catch everything thrown to him, and move the chains.
Not bad for a fourth round pick even though he went a round
earlier than where I had him graded. Bloom offers an
alternative to Avant as a third receiver. He is faster,
and this a better down field threat. While small, he is
strong. Bloom is also an excellent return man and could
turn into a contributor on both offense and special teams.
Gaither is a strong kid with good work habits. He plays
better than he tests and should be, at worst, a quality backup
and good special teams performer. Ramsey is a player the
Eagles like better than me. I thought his best shot was as
a 3-4 defensive end. I would have drafted running back
Mike Bell or Cedric Humes at this spot as a potential power back
to pair with Westbrook.
The Eagles have two college
street free agents of note in camp, one they signed, one they
traded for. Of the rookie receivers mentioned in this
anaysis (Avant, Bloom and Baskett), Baskett may have the best
chance to develop into a starter. He also has the best
chance to be out of the league in a year or three. Baskett
has a nice mix of size and speed and can make acrobatic catches.
He also drops too many balls. Ware is a smart player who
goes for the knockout hit. He could stick as a backup
safety and special teams player.
|
red indicates
workout number in top range at position in draft
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3 CONE |
BENCH |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
LONG
JUMP |
WONDER
LIC |
| Bunkley |
Florida
State |
6'2.5",
304 |
4.95 |
1.71 |
2.91 |
4.16 |
|
7.33 |
44 |
32.5" |
9'5" |
|
DT
Jay Goldberg, 900FootballLinks.NET -
Bunkley is a good inside pass rusher with excellent explosion
off the line. He may need to bulk up depending upon team
and role (could be an excellent 3-4 end).
Jay Goldberg,
900FootballLinks.NET - Bunkley showed explosion off the line at
Senior Bowl practices.
Jay Goldberg,
900FootballLinks.NET - Bunkley has an amazing combination of
strength and quickness. He will be a run-stuffing tackle,
a tackle who can engage blockers so linebackers can run free and
make tackles, and provide a good inside pass rush. In his
senior year Bunkley amassed 66 tackles, including a whopping 25
tackles for losses, and 9 sacks. |
| PLAYER |
COLLEGE |
HGT-WGHT |
FORTY
DASH |
10
DASH |
20
DASH |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
| |