|
|
CAROLINA PANTHERS
Pro
Sports Daily
Official
Site
USA
Today
Pro
Football Weekly
Panthers Stats
ESPN
2009
draft 2008
draft 2007 draft
2006 draft
2005
draft 2004
draft 2003
draft 2002
draft
2009
DRAFT PICKS
links go to
NFL.com website
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
School |
Jay's
ranking |
Jay's
draft value |
| 2 |
43 |
Everette
Brown |
DE |
Florida
State |
#3
DE |
Round
1 |
| 2 |
59 |
Sherrod
Martin |
CB/FS |
Troy |
#9
CB |
Round
3 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
Did
not stand out in one on one cover drills but looked better in 11
on 11 drills. His workout will be big for him. |
| 3 |
93 |
Corvey
Irvin |
DT |
Georgia |
#7
DT |
Round
3 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
| Irvin
had a sack in the 11 on 11's, and made a nice play on a
screen pass in the 11 on 11's. In the one-on-one's
he did best when he could bull rush the blocker. |
|
ONE
ON ONE BLOCKING DRILLS SCORED BY JAY GOLDBERG |
| 5
- 5 |
Caldwell
0-2 Parker 1-1 Luigs
2-0 Wood 1-1 Kropog 1-1 |
|
| 4 |
111 |
Mike
Goodson |
RB |
Texas
A&M |
#7
RB |
Round
3 |
| 4 |
128 |
Tony
Fiammetta |
FB |
Syracuse |
#1
FB |
Round
4 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
Known
as a very good blocker, Fiammetta had some very good run blocks
in practice. However, what impressed me the most was that
he looked great in one-on-one pass catching drills beating
defenders, making good catches and even showing YAC potential. |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher than
him. |
Fiametta
is one of the best fullback prospects I've encountered in a long
time. He is very strong; is an excellent blocker; has good
speed and quickness for a man his size; and has very good hands
and run after the catch ability. If your team selects him
higher than you thought a fullback should be picked, know you
drafted a very special player. |
| 5 |
163 |
Duke
Robinson |
OG |
Oklahoma |
#3
OG |
Round
2 |
| 7 |
216 |
Captain
Munnerlyn |
CB |
South
Carolina |
#14
CB |
Round
4 |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher than
him. |
Munnerlyn
is a very good prospect as a slot corner and return man.
He is both fast and quick; is very strong for a kid his size,
and has no problem playing physically. An ideal player to
add to a team's roster, in addition to growing into a top nickel
corner, Munnerlyn will be a core special teams player as well. |
| FA |
---- |
Gerald
Cadogan |
OT |
Penn
State |
#13
OT |
Round
4 |
| FA |
---- |
Hunter
Cantwell |
QB |
Louisville |
NR |
Late
Round Value |
| FA |
---- |
Jason
Chery |
WR |
Louisiana-Lafayette |
NR |
Late
Round Value |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher than
him. |
Chery
is one of the better special team players available in the
draft. He has very good return skills and is strong for
his size so will be good on coverage units as well.
However, Chery makes this list because reports from the Texas vs
the Nation All Star Game indicated that he caught everything
thrown his way in practice so he could surprise as a contributor
in multiple receiver sets down the line as well as on special
teams. |
| FA |
---- |
D.J.
Clark |
CB |
Idaho |
NR |
7th/FA |
| FA |
---- |
C.J.
Davis |
OG/C |
Pittsburgh |
NR |
Late
Round Value |
| FA |
---- |
D.
J. Johnson |
CB/FS |
Jackson
State |
#22
CB |
Round
5 |
|
Senior
Bowl practice comment |
Showed
some good things in coverage particularly press coverage in the
one on one's. However, was also beat often in the
one-on-one drills. He did flash a number of times,
however, in the 11 on 11's. |
| FA |
---- |
Marlon
Favorite |
DT |
LSU |
NR |
7th/FA |
| FA |
---- |
Anthony
Heygood |
OLB |
Purdue |
NR |
7th/FA |
| FA |
---- |
Mortty
Ivy |
OLB |
WEst
Virginia |
NR |
Late
Round Value |
|
A-
|
2009
COLLEGE DRAFT REPORT CARD
|
by
Jay Goldberg
|
|
Considering
the Panthers had no first round pick, getting an A- is pretty
impressive. One reason is that I don't bail on my
prospects like some draft-graders. I had a solid first
round grade on Brown. I also liked some of the Panthers'
college street free agent signings.
DRAFT
PICKS
Brown
started declining when NFL teams began questioning his ability
to play OLB in a 3-4 defense. Personally, I always liked
him as a defensive end in spite of his lack of great size for
the position. Brown is a very good pass rusher who will
start off as a nickel rusher, and grow into a starter down the
line.
Last
year the Panthers drafted a corner and successfully moved him
to safety; this year safety Martin will move to corner.
Martin has good size, acceptable speed and tremendous
quickness. He is the rare taller corner who can line up
in the slot against short, quick receivers and taller West
Coast Offense receivers. He will need some time to fully
develop but will be a solid player for Carolina for years.
Some
circles called Irvin a reach but not me. He needs a bit
more work in the weight room but has the skills to be a good
NFL player.
While
the Eagles got rave reviews for drafting McCoy in round two, I
had Goodson with a slightly higher grade and they grabbed him
in round four. My only question is with Williams and
Stewart, what is the Panthers' long term plan for their
running backs. Personally, I could see them showcasing
the injury-prone Stewart and moving him for a high draft
pick. This would allow Goodson to settle in as the #2
back in tandem with Williams. If that isn't the plan, as
much as I like Goodson, tight end Shawn Nelson may have been a
better selection here for the long term. And if not
Nelson, receivers Johnny Knox or Jarett Dillard could also
have been better long term pieces for the Panther offense.
Fiammetta
is the rare fullback deserving of being selected using a
quality pick. In fact the combination of Goodson and
Fiammetta could make my conjecture of a Stewart trade more
likely. Fiammetta is very strong, an excellent blocker,
has good hands, and has excellent speed for a fullback.
He could be used as a short-yardage back in addition to
playing the traditional fullback role at a high level.
In that role, I like him more than McClain of the Ravens.
Robinson
was great value in round five. He has good size and is a
natural talent. In the NFL Robinson will not be able to
play at a consistently high level on his natural abilities
alone. He will need to work harder to have become a
dependable starter.
While
Robinson was excellent value in round five, Munnerlyn was a
steal in round seven. He did not have a great workout at
the Combine but rebounded with a very good Pro Day.
While short, Munnerlyn is strong, quick, athletic and
confident. This is one seventh round pick who will have
a long successful NFL career.
COLLEGE
STREET FREE AGENTS
Cadogan
was one of the better college street free agent
signings. Look for him to make the Panthers'
roster. He has good size, quick feet and long arms. Cantwell
is an interesting case. Before the season many thought
he could be one of the top quarterbacks in the draft.
However, he played inconsistently after riding the bench
behind Brian Brohm for three years. He is for the
developmental squad. Chery
has a legit shot to make the Panthers' regular season roster
and be active on game day. He is a top return man and
showed good hands during Texas vs. the Nation practices. Clark
is a good athlete who will have a difficult time making the
Panthers' roster since two corners were added in the
draft. He could land on the development squad. Davis
is a kid with quick feet and the versatility to play guard or
center. He has a chance to develop into a reliable
backup. Johnson
saw his draft stock fall after he lifted the bar a paltry 7
times and was not as athletic as advertised. Still, he
has good on-field instincts. Johnson is an ideal
development squad candidate. Favorite
will have a tough time making the opening day roster, he has
good size but limited athleticism. If
Heygood shows he can fill in at linebacker he could make a run
at a roster spot since he will be a good special teams
player. Ivy
is a bit of a tweener. He is an outside linebacker built
more like an inside linebacker. However, he lacks the
change-of-direction skills to play inside in a 4-3
defense. I thought his best chance to stick would be to
move inside for a 3-4 defense. |
For
chart below: red indicates workout number in top range at position in
draft
ARM-HAND
relative to position, for ranges see ranking pages for 2009 draft
LAST
NAME
at Combine |
FIRST
NAME |
SCHOOL |
HGT |
WGT |
ARM-
HAND |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT |
LONG |
3
CONE |
VERT |
BROAD |
| Brown |
Everette |
Florida
State |
6'1.4" |
256 |
M-L |
26 |
4.63 |
1.59 |
2.68 |
4.53 |
- |
7.58 |
31.5" |
9'9" |
| Martin |
Sherrod |
Troy |
6'1" |
198 |
M-S |
12 |
4.46 |
1.51 |
2.57 |
3.98 |
11.17 |
6.60 |
36.5" |
10'3" |
| Irvin |
Corvey |
Georgia |
6'3" |
301 |
L-M |
24 |
4.96 |
1.71 |
2.81 |
4.66 |
- |
7.44 |
25" |
8'7" |
| Goodson |
Mike |
Texas
A&M |
5'11.7" |
212 |
L-L |
14 |
4.43 |
1.49 |
2.59 |
4.22 |
- |
6.89 |
39.5" |
9'10" |
| Fiametta |
Tony |
Syracuse |
6'0.1" |
245 |
XL-XL |
30 |
4.63 |
1.57 |
2.62 |
4.33 |
- |
7.03 |
34" |
9'4" |
| Robinson |
Duke |
Oklahoma |
6'4.6" |
329 |
L-XL |
20 |
5.27 |
1.76 |
3.03 |
4.90 |
- |
8.09 |
31.5" |
8'3" |
| Munnerlyn |
Captain |
South
Carolina |
5'8.4" |
182 |
M-S |
19 |
4.41 |
1.48 |
2.55 |
4.04 |
- |
7.05 |
37.5" |
10'1" |
| Cadogan |
Gerald |
Penn
State |
6'5.1" |
309 |
XL-M |
26 |
4.99 |
1.75 |
2.96 |
4.80 |
- |
8.05 |
25" |
8'3" |
| Cantwell |
Hunter |
Louisville |
6'4.3" |
235 |
XL-XL |
- |
5.17 |
1.69 |
3.00 |
4.59 |
- |
7.40 |
26" |
8'3" |
| Chery |
Jason |
Louisiana-Laf |
5'10.3" |
189 |
- |
19 |
4.45 |
1.49 |
2.59 |
- |
- |
- |
39" |
- |
| Clark |
D.J. |
Idaho |
6'1.1" |
200 |
- |
14 |
4.52 |
1.56 |
2.58 |
4.01 |
- |
6.91 |
36" |
10'7" |
| Davis |
C.J. |
Pittsburgh |
6'2" |
308 |
S-M |
23 |
5.54 |
1.84 |
3.15 |
4.62 |
- |
7.64 |
26.5" |
7'4" |
| Johnson |
D.J. |
Jackson
State |
6'1.3" |
197 |
L-XL |
7 |
4.50 |
1.50 |
2.57 |
4.28 |
- |
7.00 |
32" |
9'8" |
| Favorite |
Marlon |
LSU |
6'0.7" |
314 |
M-XL |
26 |
5.09 |
1.74 |
2.66 |
5.27 |
- |
8.02 |
18.5" |
7'0" |
| Heygood |
Anthony |
Purdue |
6'0.3" |
225 |
- |
18 |
4.67 |
1.61 |
2.68 |
4.30 |
- |
7.10 |
33.5" |
10'10" |
| Ivy |
Mortty |
West
Virginia |
6'1.4" |
248 |
S-M |
18 |
4.78 |
1.61 |
2.77 |
4.44 |
- |
7.15 |
28.5" |
9'2" |
2009 NEEDS PRIOR TO DRAFT AND FREE
AGENCY
Major need
Need
Upgrade possible
Depth/possible need
Not a need
| QB |
Except for the Panthers'
biggest game of the year, their playoff game, Delhomme's
comeback from injury was a success. At one time Moore
showed promise but he hasn't maintained it. McCown is an
okay backup. The Panthers may think about drafting a
quarter they can groom as a future starter. |
| RB |
I had DeAngelo Williams
graded much higher than other backs who were graded by other
analysts higher than or as his equal. That included
Maroney, White and Addai. So I was not surprised to see
his success. Look for Williams to continue to hold off
Stewart as starter. However, Stewart provides a great
tandem with and excellent insurance for Williams. Goings
is a fine third back who has played well in his career when
given opportunities. |
| WR |
Smith and Muhammad are a
great starting combo. Hackett was disappointing and I'm
not sure Jarrett will ever grow into more than a #4.
Therefore, Carolina needs a wideout who can play in the slot for
a couple of years, and take over for Muhammad in a couple of
years. |
| TE |
Just think what a tight
end that could stretch the field would mean to this team.
King is okay, Rosario flashed, and Barnidge has potential, but a
big-time tight end could make this offense very very tough to
stop. Defenses have to stack the box against
Williams/Stewart, have to double Smith, have to be cautious of
Muhammad, and that would leave a tight end with speed one on one
with a linebacker often. |
| OL |
Gross is an UFA and
signing him is considered a higher priority than signing
Peppers. That should tell you how good he is. If the
Panthers resign Gross they will return a very good line with
good depth. If not they will need to address left tackle. |
| DL |
Peppers is an UFA and
Brayton is okay but could be replaced by Johnson. If
Peppers is gone (like he wants) Carolina will need a dominate
pass rusher. At tackle, Lewis and Kemoeatu are solid but
if a game-changer could be secured it would upgrade the unit.
Worst case they did a tackle for depth. |
| LB |
Davis and Beason are top
starters. Diggs is a reliable veteran, who could be pushed
by Connor. Landon Johnson is also on hand but he didn't
play as well as he did for the Bengals. The Panthers will
add depth here this offseason. |
| DB |
This is a solid unit top
to bottom. Gamble, Lucas and Marshall are all
starting-caliber NFL corners. Wilson is a young corner
with promise. Strong safety Harris has played well since
coming over from the Bears, and free safety Godfrey was a good
looking rookie who will only get better. In fact, I look
for Godfrey to become a good playmaker. Teal and Salley
are okay backup safeties, but competition will brought in for
them. |
| ST |
Long snapper Kyle is an
UFA, but he will most likely be brought back.
Returner Mark Jones is also an UFA. Their kicking/punting
game is in good hands. |
2008
DRAFT PICKS
links go to
NFL.com website
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
Ht. |
Wt. |
School |
Jay's ranking |
Jay's draft value |
| 1 |
13 |
Jonathan
Stewart |
RB |
5'10.2" |
235 |
Oregon |
#3 RB |
Round 1 |
| 1 |
19 |
Jeff
Otah |
OT |
6'6" |
332 |
Pittsburgh |
#4 OT |
Round 1 |
| 3 |
67 |
Charles
Godfrey |
CB/FS |
5'11.6" |
207 |
Iowa |
#7 CB |
Round 2 |
|
Player
who will have a better NFL career than many drafted higher
than him.
|
Godfrey
isn't the faster corner, isn't the quickest corner, isn't the
most athletic corner, but he is a very good football player.
He played at a consistently high level during both Senior Bowl
practices and in the game. Godfrey can play in either a
man or cover-two scheme. |
| 3 |
74 |
Dan
Connor |
OLB/ILB |
6'2.3" |
231 |
Penn St |
#2 ILB |
Round 2 |
| 5 |
141 |
Gary
Barnidge |
TE |
6'5.5" |
243 |
Louisville |
#8 TE |
Round 4 |
| 6 |
181 |
Nick
Hayden |
DT |
6'3.6" |
291 |
Wisconsin |
#16 DT |
Round 4/Round 5 |
| 7 |
221 |
Hilee
Taylor |
OLB/DE |
6'2.5" |
242 |
N Carolina |
|
Late Round Value |
| 7 |
241 |
Geoff
Schwartz |
OT/OG |
6'6.1" |
332 |
Oregon |
|
Late Round
Value/Free Agent |
| 7 |
250 |
Mackenzy
Bernadeau |
OG |
6'3.5" |
298 |
Bentley |
|
Free Agent |
| FA |
|
Darren Toney |
CB/RET |
5'11" |
184 |
Ark St |
|
Free Agent |
|
If
I didn't believe that DeAngelo Williams could be a top every
down running back, this draft would have a grade of
"A-". However, I would have drafted OT Chris
Williams in round one and targeted RB Tashard Choice to be the
power back compliment to Williams. If the Panthers
drafted Chris Williams (or Otah if they thad him rated higher)
they would still have their first round pick next year (no
need to trade to get Otah) and could have added DE Campbell in
round two (a need position not addressed in the draft) and RB
Choice in round four. Personally, I like my #1 next
year, OT Williams (or Otah), DE Campbell and RB Choice, more
than RB Stewart. That said, the Panthers added good
players and got excellent value with Godfrey, Connor, Barnidge
and Hayden. I especially like the potential of Godfrey.
So far, they have not done anything of major consequence as
far as college street free agents go.
DRAFT
PICKS
Stewart
is very strong, powerful, fast for his size, and a good
athlete. That said, he has had some injury problems, and
I'm not convinced he won't be more like T. J. Duckett than
Marion Barber. If Coach Fox isn't stubborn, DeAngelo
Williams could be the main ball-carrier for Carolina this
year.
Otah
is a big strong offensive tackle who is better in the run game
than the passing game which is why some thought right tackle
might be a better fit for him in the NFL.
Godfrey
is a player with excellent potential. He could be an
excellent corner or a top free safety. As a corner he is
better outside than lining up against slot receivers. As
a safety. he'll make big plays and can fill against the run.
An excellent selection for Carolina.
Boy
did Connor fall in this draft. Still he is a football
player. While some may have downgraded him because he is
not a top athlete, he locates and moves to the ball very
quickly and will be an above average starter in the NFL.
Barnidge
was another excellent get by Carolina. At this point he
is strictly a pass catching tight end, but he has the attitude
and build to become a plus as a blocker as well.
Barnidge has good speed and quickness and should make some big
plays as opposing teams concentrate on Steve Smith.
Strong,
quick and athletic is how I would describe Nick Hayden.
He is not the run-stuffing defensive tackle but can make plays
in pursuit and could be an inside rusher in the nickel.
Taylor
is an outside linebacker, defensive end tweener, Taylor has
some upside as a special teams player and situational pass
rusher.
Schwartz
is a big body guy who needs development and is a good
candidate for the Panthers' practice squad. If he shows
enough in camp ands is a quick learner, he could stick on the
main roster because he can play multip0le positions on the
line.
Berenadeau
had a nice workout which moved him onto NFL teams' radars.
He has a chance to develop into a good backup guard. He
has quick feet and good athleticsm and could become a plus in
the running game.
COLLEGE
STREET FREE AGENTS
As
of this write-up, the Ravens did not sign any college street
free agents who I had rated Late Round Value or higher.
Toney is listed because of his kick return ability more than
his talent at corner.
|
red
indicates workout number in top range at position in draft
(blue
college name indicates workout #'s include Pro Day numbers)
COMBINE
YES |
FIRST
NAME |
SCHOOL |
HEIGHT |
WEIGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT |
LONG |
3
CONE |
VERT |
BROAD |
| Stewart |
Jonathan |
OREGON |
5'10.2" |
235 |
28 |
4.48 |
1.54 |
2.56 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
36.5" |
10'8" |
| Otah |
Jeff |
PITTSBURGH |
6'6" |
332 |
27 |
5.28 |
1.92 |
3.10 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
22.5" |
8'6" |
| Godfrey |
Charles |
IOWA |
5'11.6" |
207 |
14 |
4.38 |
1.43 |
2.53 |
4.40 |
NA |
7.28 |
37.5" |
10'1" |
| Connor |
Dan |
PENN
STATE |
6'2.3" |
231 |
21 |
4.67 |
1.58 |
2.70 |
4.25 |
NA |
6.78 |
35" |
9'7" |
| Barnidge |
Gary |
LOUISVILLE |
6'5.5" |
243 |
22 |
4.63 |
1.53 |
2.62 |
4.23 |
11.29 |
6.92 |
31" |
9'9" |
| Hayden |
Nick |
WISCONSIN |
6'3.6" |
291 |
34 |
5.24 |
1.80 |
3.01 |
4.54 |
NA |
7.25 |
32" |
9'4" |
| Taylor |
Hilee |
N
CAROLINA |
6'2.5" |
242 |
NA |
4.58 |
1.59 |
2.64 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
| Schwartz |
Geoff |
OREGON |
6'6.1" |
332 |
NA |
5.32 |
1.80 |
3.04 |
4.79 |
NA |
7.90 |
20.5" |
8'2" |
| Benadeau |
Mackenzy |
BENTLEY |
6'3.5" |
298 |
26 |
5.35 |
1.76 |
2.99 |
4.56 |
NA |
7.47 |
28.5" |
9'1" |
| Toney |
Darren |
ARKANSAS
ST |
5'11" |
184 |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
2008 NEEDS
PRIOR TO DRAFT AND FREE AGENCY
CAR
Major
Need Need
Upgrade Depth
Need Not
a Need
| QB |
After
the "Carr-wreck", maybe the Panthers will appreciate
Delhomme more. Speaking of more, Moore showed some
skills and should be Delhomme's backup next year. The
Panthers also like Basanez. If a QB drops in the draft
or if an intriguing veteran gets cut the Panthers will take a
shot, otherwise they'll stick with what they have. |
| RB |
Hello
... is anybody there .... it's time to give the ball to
DeAngelo Williams 20+ times a game. I can see the
Panthers cutting Foster and bringing in both a veteran looking
for a home and a player in the draft. |
| WR |
Carter
and Colbert are both free agents. That's okay because
neither is the answer opposite Smith. The Panthers need
a starter and at least one backup who can compete for the
third receiver role. |
| TE |
KIng
and Rosario are fine players. There is no great urgency
to upgrade. However, if the Panthers can add a dominate
tight end it would take some of the heat off Smith. Just
look at what Witten does in tandem with Owens. |
| OL |
Gross
and Wharton are free agents. The Panthers will have to
re-sign them or bring on some players to compete for their
jobs. Even of they come back the Panthers will look to
upgrade their line. |
| DL |
The
Panthers need an end to play opposite Peppers. Johnson
could develop into a good #3. With Lewis and Moorehead
free agents, depth at tackle may also be needed. |
| LB |
Despite
re-signing Diggs, the Panthers need a WILL linebacker.
Beason and Davis a re solid at the MIKE and SAM. Depth
is also needed. |
| DB |
Carolina
has three good corners. Harris played well at strong
safety but drafting a young player to push him would be a good
idea. Cooper was fine at free safety, but an upgrade
would help the defense. |
| ST |
Kasay
is still effective but he no longer can boom kickoffs.
Competition will be brought in for Baker. The Panthers
need a better return man so they can forget about even being
tempted to use Smith. |
2007
DRAFT PICKS
links go to
NFL.com website
| Rd |
Sel# |
Player |
Pos. |
Ht. |
Wt. |
School |
Jay's ranking |
Jay's draft value |
| 1 |
25 |
Beason,
Jon |
OLB |
6-0 |
236 |
Miami
(Fla.) |
#2 OLB |
Round 1 |
| 2 |
45 |
Jarrett,
Dwayne |
WR |
6-5 |
213 |
Southern
California |
# 9 WR |
Round 2 |
| 2 |
59 |
Kalil,
Ryan |
C |
6-3 |
291 |
Southern
California |
# 1 C |
Round 1 |
| 3 |
83 |
Johnson,
Charles |
DE |
6-2 |
272 |
Georgia |
# 4 DE |
Round 2 |
| 4 |
118 |
Robinson,
Ryne |
WR |
5-8 |
178 |
Miami
(Ohio) |
|
Late Round Value |
| 5 |
155 |
Rosario,
Dante |
TE |
6-3 |
244 |
Oregon |
|
Late Round Value |
| 5 |
164 |
Shaw,
Tim |
ILB |
6-1 |
237 |
Penn
State |
# 5 OLB |
Round 2 |
| 7 |
226 |
Wilson,
C.J. |
CB |
6-1 |
195 |
Baylor |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Bell, Dalton |
QB |
6-2 |
206 |
West Texas A&M |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Bennett, Nathan |
OG |
6-4 |
316 |
Clemson |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Biggs, Rondell |
DE |
6-2 |
269 |
Michigan |
|
Off My Board |
| FA |
|
Daniels, Jesse |
SS |
5-11 |
216 |
LSU |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Gilmour, Jahnkeen |
WR |
6-0 |
205 |
Indiana |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Pimentel, Mickey |
OLB |
6-2 |
228 |
California |
|
Late Round Value |
| FA |
|
Upshaw, Chad |
TE |
6-4 |
252 |
Buffalo |
|
Late Round Value |
|
The
Panthers had a nice draft. They got excellent value with
Tim Shaw on day two and Charles Johnson in round three was a
good get as well. I didn't see any college street free
agents that jumped out at me, although Jesse Daniels may have
the best shot since Carolina was expected to draft a safety and
did not.
Beason
was a needed pick. Between the loss of Meriweather last
year, and Morgan's concussions, a tackle-hound-type of a
linebacker was critical for the Panthers to add in the draft.
Assuming Morgan stays healthy, Beason will probably start
outside his rookie year (with Davis). If (when?) Morgan
goes down again, Beason can slide inside and man the position he
will eventually fill long term for the team. Jarrett went
where I had him graded, in round two. He will be a good
possession receiver with reliable hands. To become a
Keyshawn Johnson he will have to become stronger. He is
more like a Reggie Williams or Joe Jurevicious. However,
Jarrett can become a solid #2. Kalil was my top rated
center. He will be hard to keep on the bench. The
kid loves to play, is very strong and very tough, and has all
the measurables. Johnson was another player of need for
the Panthers. Witrh Rucker seemingly on the decline, and
Wallace gone, a young defensive end was a major need for
Carolina. Johnson was good value in round three (I had a
second round grade on him). He fell a bit in the draft
because he is not (and will probably never be) a stud sacker.
However, he is solid against the run and could get a team 6 to 8
sacks if playing opposite an end that teams have to constantly
double-team (such as Peppers). Robinson's value is as a
return man. With Steve Smith and DeAngelo Williams keys to
the Panthers' offense, the team will be best served if they only
use those two on special teams in special circumstances.
Robinson could allow for that. Rosario is athletic and can
catch, but may be a man without a true position. He is
small for a tight end, and is not good blocker. He was
tried at fullback in college and that wasn't a great fit.
Still, he can help on special teams and be used in obvious
passing downs on offense. However, a safety like Wendling
or Stone would have been my pick. Tim Shaw was a great
pick in round five. I had a second round grade on this
terrific athlete. Shaw had some of the best numbers
amongst outside linebackers in the draft, and is a good football
player. Down the line I see the Panthers lining up Davis
at the WILL, Beason at the MIKE, and Shaw at the SAM.
Wilson is type of player team's need for depth. He has
good size and above average corner skills. He may only see
the field if a starting corner goes down, but if that corner
goes down he could help save a season. Wilson does not,
however, have the quickness needed to be a nickel who covers
slot receivers.
As
far as college street free agents go, Bell was a very productive
small school quarterback who could find a home on the Panthers'
development squad. Bennett is a strong kid who needs work,
but goes after his opponent. He is another possible
development squad candidate. Biggs came on late in his
career and has some potential as a pass rusher. He will
have to show further growth in camp to stick, even on the
development squad. Daniels may have the best chance of the
college street free agents to stick because the team needs to
look at young safeties. Daniels is an in-the-box strong
safety, who needs work on pass coverage and on wrapping up
better when he tackles. Personally, if I were Panther
management I would have made a run at Melvin Bullitt in free
agency, he was my best undrafted strong safety. Gilmore
was not on anyone's radar until he ran 4.43 forty at his Pro Day
while lifting the bar 20 times. Both are very good numbers
for wide receivers. He is certainly worth a look in camp.
Pimentel is a good athlete who needs to learn more about playing
linebacker. If he shows something in camp he could stick
on the development squad. Upshaw was known for both his
pass catching and blocking at Buffalo, and has the frame to add
the weight he will need to be productive in the NFL. If
bloodlines mean anything, his father is former Toronto Blue Jay
Willie Upshaw, and his uncle is Gene Upshaw.
|
red
indicates workout number in top range at position in draft
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| BEASON |
JON |
MIAMI-FL |
OLB/ILB |
6'0.2" |
237 |
19 |
4.64 |
1.60 |
2.74 |
|
|
|
|
9'3" |
| Beason
can play the WILL or MIKE in a 4-3, and possibly inside in a
3-4. Beason is a better football player than workout
warrior. On the field he plays with a take no prisoners
attitude, and has good instincts and makes tackles all over the
field. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| JARRETT |
DWAYNE |
SOUTHERN
CAL |
WR
|
6'4" |
219 |
|
4.62 |
1.58 |
2.64 |
4.20 |
|
7.28 |
36.5" |
10'1" |
| Jarrett
is a big target with good hands. His speed and athleticism
are just okay. While some compare him to former USC player
Mike Williams, I have him pegged more like Reggie Williams of
Jacksonville. Jarrett will have value to the NFL that
drafts him, but he won't be a star. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| KALIL |
RYAN |
SOUTHERN
CAL |
OC |
6'2.6" |
299 |
34 |
4.96 |
1.71 |
2.87 |
4.34 |
|
7.50 |
26" |
8'8" |
| Kalil
is my top rated center in the draft. He had an excellent
week of practice at the Senior Bowl and is a master technician.
Kalili is an excellent athlete for the position with speed,
quickness, strength, and athleticism. He is a tough kid
who loves to play football. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| JOHNSON |
CHARLES |
GEORGIA |
DE |
6'2.2" |
270 |
33 |
4.75 |
1.58 |
2.74 |
|
|
7.50 |
34" |
9'10" |
| Johnson
is a strong kid who outplayed his more heralded teammate,
Quentin Moses, last year. Johnson can play the run and
rush the passer, although he will never be a stud sacker.
Johnson is the type of steady player who teams can rely on when
offenses move the action away from a star end playing on the
other side. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| ROBINSON |
RYNE |
MIAMI-OH |
WR/RET
|
5'9.1" |
179 |
|
4.47 |
|
|
4.21 |
11.43 |
6.84 |
35" |
9'4" |
| Robinson
returned punts and kickoffs at the Intra Juice All Star game and
he looked fast. He was okay as a receiver, but appears to
have potential as a return man who can also fill in at receiver
if needed. |
|
MBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| ROSARIO |
DANTE |
OREGON |
TE
|
6'3.2" |
244 |
20 |
4.76 |
1.65 |
2.81 |
4.21 |
|
6.91 |
36" |
9'10" |
| Rosario
is a good receiving tight end, but he lacks size and is not a
good blocker. As an athlete, he could help a club on
special teams, and could be inserted into the offense on obvious
passing downs. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| SHAW |
TIM |
PENN
ST |
OLB |
6'1.4" |
236 |
26 |
4.46 |
1.49 |
2.54 |
4.12 |
|
6.90 |
36.5" |
10'6" |
|
PLAYER
WHO COULD HAVE A BETTER NFL CAREER THAN PLAYERS SELECTED AHEAD
OF HIM in the DRAFT
|
| Shaw,
who played defensive end in college, is a bit short, but has the
strength, speed and athleticism to play OLB or ILB in the NFL.
In fact, he should be able to transition to the SAM in a 4-3, as
well as a pass rushing outside linebacker in a 3-4. He is
also the type of athlete that a team like the Patriots likes to
move to inside linebacker in their 3-4. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| WILSON |
C
J |
BAYLOR |
CB |
6'1.2" |
195 |
12 |
4.52 |
1.50 |
2.60 |
4.20 |
11.30 |
6.81 |
37.5" |
10'7" |
| Wilson
has good size for a corner and decent speed and quickness.
He could develop into a solid NFL corner, one who is best served
as a backup for a team's starters than as a nickel covering the
slot receiver. However, he could help save a team's season
if a starter goes down. |
|
COMBINE
NO
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| BELL |
DALTON |
WEST
TEX A&M |
QB
|
6'2.1" |
206 |
|
4.75 |
1.63 |
2.74 |
4.43 |
|
7.42 |
34" |
9'6" |
| Bell
is an extremely productive small school quarterback. In
consecutive championships he threw for over 7,500 yards and 62
touchdowns. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| BENNETT |
NATHAN |
CLEMSON |
OG |
6'4.3" |
316 |
34 |
5.47 |
1.82 |
3.06 |
4.85 |
|
7.90 |
26.5" |
7'9" |
| Bennett
is a strong kid who will need to work on his technique to stick
on the next level. |
|
COMBINE
NO
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| BIGGS |
DANIEL |
MICHIGAN |
DE
|
6'1.5" |
269 |
|
4.91 |
1.76 |
2.85 |
4.59 |
|
7.53 |
31.5" |
9'3" |
| Biggs
came on late in his college career and became a solid player
opposite LaMarr Woodley. He has a chance to get into a
camp and stick as a backup defensive end. He has some pass
rush skills. |
|
COMBINE
YES
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
40 |
10 |
20 |
SHORT
SHUTTLE |
LONG
SHUTTLE |
3
CONE |
VERTICAL
JUMP |
BROAD
JUMP |
| DANIELS |
JESSE |
LOUISIANA
ST |
SS |
5'10.7" |
216 |
25 |
4.54 |
1.55 |
2.60 |
4.25 |
|
7.12 |
33.5" |
10'0" |
| Daniels
is an in-the-box safety who plays the run better than he plays
the pass. He has good strength, but needs to go for the
sure tackle more often, rather than the big hit. |
|
COMBINE
NO
|
|
COLLEGE
|
POS |
HGHT |
WGHT |
BENCH |
| |